ConsequenceWheel
Menu

Behavior

Consequences for hitting

Hitting needs a clear limit and a replacement skill. If spanking is one of your agreed options, it is parent-chosen, you can turn it off, and it is calm, never in anger, not a reaction in the moment. The AAP advises against corporal punishment, including spanking.

First see whether anyone is hurt. Ice, a bandage, or a call for help comes before any wheel. If hitting is frequent, scary, or you are afraid someone will get injured, talk with a pediatrician rather than hunting for a bigger penalty.

Free wheel

Preset: Consequences for hitting

The wheel only chooses options you leave switched on. Agree on them before anyone is upset, and follow through calm, never in anger.

Add a name if you want it in the result. Spin when the list feels fair.

Consequences on the wheel

Switch suggestions off, edit the wording, reorder them, or add your own.

  • Check they are okay

    Ice, a tissue, or space. Care comes before the lesson.

  • Gentle hands practice

    Show soft hands on a pillow, then try the moment again.

  • Play pauses

    The game or toy involved stops. Name when it can restart.

    Amount 5–20 minutes

  • Move to a quiet spot

    Nearby and boring. Stay where you can see them.

  • Calm-down time

    Short and pre-agreed. Narrow the range to about a minute per year of age if you want.

    Amount 1–5 minutes

  • Redo with words

    Give them one sentence to try: “I’m mad” or “Stop.”

  • Help them feel better

    A comfort the other child accepts. No forced hug.

  • Make a restart plan

    How the game begins again, and what hands will do.

Add your own

Stop the contact, then teach the hands

Child Mind Institute’s guidance on time-out says to respond quickly, with few words, and to have decided ahead of time which behaviors lead there. “No hitting. Calm-down spot.” is enough. Skip the lecture while everyone is hot.

Mississippi State’s examples of logical consequences keep the child connected to the act: if they cannot play safely with the toy or the sibling, that play pauses. They can watch, or they can practice gentle hands and try again.

Repair is part of the consequence

After bodies are calm, the child checks on the person they hurt. Offer a tissue, an ice pack, or a quiet “I won’t hit.” Do not demand a performance apology.

Put “gentle hands practice” on the wheel so the spin sometimes lands on the skill, not only on a loss. Kids need a picture of what to do with their hands.

Leave these off the list

  • Hitting back in the moment, or a spanking decided while you are angry.
  • Shaming them as mean or bad in front of the other child.
  • Forcing a hug before the other child wants one.
  • Using food, such as no dinner, as the price of a hit.

Words you can use

  • “I will not let you hit. I am moving you to the calm spot.”
  • “Hands stay in your lap. We can try the game again when your body is quiet.”
  • “Check if your brother is okay. Ask if he wants a tissue.”
  • “The game is paused. The wheel will pick how we restart.”

Questions parents ask

Is a time-out the right consequence for hitting?

It can be one option, if it is short and not shaming. HealthyChildren describes about one minute per year of age as a rule of thumb. Also keep a slice for practicing gentle hands and a slice for pausing the game.

What if they hit me, the parent?

Block gently, move away, and use the same short script. Do not hit back. If you cannot stay safe, get another adult and get guidance from a clinician.

Should hitting always spin the harshest slice?

No. You choose which slices are enabled before the day starts. If you only want play to pause after hitting, turn the other slices off. The wheel should not surprise you with a result you dislike.

Sources